reviewer

Ron ****

review date 04/16/2014 overall rating
Thank you Carlene for contacting me, responding very quickly, taking me out and viewing all great apartments within my budget and specifics. You are a great broker, did your job well and mastered the art of professionalism. I thank you for that!
However, I did not rent the apt with you because of the company you work for. I read many stories of this company and as a new to NYC resident, I prefer to be safe than sorry.
Carlene informed me each office is independently owned and operated and I shouldn't believe everything I read. I did do some research for myself and read all great reviews about her and decided to give her one for myself. Maybe I'm a bit closed-minded but when you are unaware brings fear.
If anyone is looking for an honest, prompt, professional, and genuine broker I recommend Carlene. I felt bad and offered her a couple hundred dollars for her time and surprisingly she refused. Guess that says a lot.

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

Carlene McCaul Responded:
My job is to find you an apt of your liking; which I did. It is not take a couple of hundred dollars you feel is compensation for my time. Thank you for the review.
reviewer

Amy ****

review date 07/30/2013 overall rating
She is calm, pleasant, professional, informed and I'm looking forward to working with her.

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Krystle ****

review date 07/19/2013 overall rating
Very professional, responded quickly via text and when I called early in the morning.

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Julian ****

review date 06/17/2013 overall rating
Carlene is personable and quite helpful. She comes prepared with information on every apartment and makes sure that she only shows you places that are within your specifications. No "Well, I thought you might like this one despite it being outside of the areas you specified and the price range." SHe's also considerate of your time. The biggest reason for my very positive rating, however, is her personality - she's a blast to go apartment visiting with! Very fun and easy to chat with.

But why a 4, as opposed to a 5? I'm hard to please, a do-it-yourselfer, and a penny-pincher. It's hard for me to justify paying anyone as much as most New Yorkers do to find them an apartment when you're someone with the time and energy to do it yourself. But if you need a broker to do the work for you, consider Carlene! I'm glad I did.

I rented an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Hilary ****

review date 04/08/2013 overall rating
Great communication and willing to help!

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Lauren ****

review date 04/08/2013 overall rating
Megan was very accomodating and great to work with!

I rented an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Kay ****

review date 04/02/2013 overall rating
Nice, smart, courteous.

I rented an apartment from this agent.

Where are these reviews from?

From renters on www.nakedapartments.com who've worked with Carlene.