Nicole Winthrop Photo

Nicole Winthrop
Oxford Property Group

(5)

With an approach rooted in cultivating face-to-face relationships and customizing transactions to her client's needs, Nicole has been distinguished as a top producing agent, having ushered in deals with new developments, like Related's MiMa in Clinton and UDR's 808 Columbus Ave on the Upper West Side, as well as collaborating with numerous agents on exclusive listings. Her name and business acumen are recognized by some of the city's most reputable landlords and management companies, having closed deals stretching from FiDi to Harlem, as well as in Williamsburg and Crown Heights.

"My very first deal was back in 2012. It was late August when I got a frantic call from two students trying to find an apartment over the Labor Day holiday weekend. They had been beaten by another application on a previous apartment through another broker and were desperate to find a place quickly because school was starting. After about 20 phone calls, I was able to gain access to 3 apartments that fit their preferences and needs. They chose one, applied, signed leases, and moved all within the span of 24 hours. I was on it from start to finish, and the girls were extremely happy with their new apartment. They then referred me to a friend, who later rented an apartment through me in Brooklyn."

Nicole is a proud member and supporter of REBNY, the Harlem Business Alliance, and the NYC Small Business Association, and has received training in marketing and sales at NYU. She practices Bikram Yoga and enjoys spending her free time with family, friends, and volunteering. Nicole is a firm believer in doing things the right way and values respect and excellence. Originally from the West Coast, Nicole has been a New Yorker since 2007.

Renter Reviews of Nicole

reviewer

Joel ****

review date
02/10/2014
overall rating
Nicole was fantastic and found us a few apartments that fit our criteria. She wasn't pushy about getting us into a fee apt, even though we chose one because it was a bit better than the 2nd choice that was no fee. By far the best broker we dealt with during the search and would recommend her to friends searching for a place.

I rented an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Alicia ****

review date
05/07/2013
overall rating
I was in a time crunch when another apartment (with another broker) fell through. It was literally 2 days before I had to move and I was frantic to find a place for myself and my 7 year old to live. I emailed Nicole at 1AM and told her I neeeeeded to see a particular apartment in TriBeCa. When I woke up in the morning there was a message from her with an appointment scheduled to see the place. When we arrived we learned that it had JUST rented and the only other places in the building were too expensive for me. Nicole worked her magic with the leasing office and got them to show us a newly vacated apartment that hadn't even come on the market yet. She negotiated a tempting 2 months free for me and helped me finesse my unusual financial situation with the leasing office til we had a plan we all felt comfortable with. The very next day I was approved and signing a lease. All this amazing service and NO FEE? Nicole is my hero agent extraordinaire. Above and beyond the call of duty.

I rented an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Abdullah ****

review date
12/11/2012
overall rating
We're still looking at places, that's why I haven't rented yet, but it's just a matter of time. Nicole is great, flexible and knowledgeable.

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Matthew ****

review date
11/02/2012
overall rating
I cannot recommend Nicole highly enough as your broker of choice for finding an apartment in NYC!

I had a very extreme circumstance of having to move immediately, and Nicole worked with me tirelessly for a week straight to find me my ideal apartment. She was completely thorough, honest, compassionate, and most of all, dedicated! Before walking around 5 different neighborhoods, she made sure to prepare me for everything the management company was going to ask for, and when it was time for the application process we had everything ready to go. We signed leases at the end of the week and I couldn't be happier with my new apartment. I have heard horror stories of NYC brokers, but Nicole has wiped those stories from my memory- she's the best!

I rented an apartment from this agent.

reviewer

Monique ****

review date
11/02/2012
overall rating
Nicole was awesome! Would definitely recommend her in a heartbeat.

I rented an apartment from this agent.

Nicole's Apartments

1br, Chelsea, $3,395

1br, Chelsea, $3,395

No fee
Pets Allowed, Elevator, In-Unit Laundry, Dishwasher, On-site super, Elevator Building
7 Days since update
1br, Chelsea, $3,495

1br, Chelsea, $3,495

No fee
Pets Allowed, Elevator, Laundry Room, On-site super, Elevator/Laundry Building
6 Days since update
1br, Chelsea, $3,350

1br, Chelsea, $3,350

Elevator, Laundry Room, Dishwasher, On-site super, Elevator/Laundry Building
6 Days since update
View all

Share Nicole's profile

Nicole's Specialties

Manhattan

Chelsea, Flatiron District, Lower East Side, Meatpacking District, Midtown Center, Midtown South Central, NoLita, SoHo, West Village