Colleen Koltick

Real Estate License
Overall Rating: (5)
Brokerage: Citi Habitats
Colleen Koltick Photo

Colleen’s real estate experience is diverse, having worked in residential, commercial and new development; but the one constant is her ability to exceed her clients' expectations. Colleen considers everyone she represents as her "partner," and views each encounter as a shared journey. With her warm nature, charismatic personality, strong business sense and entrepreneurial spirit, she makes your real estate experience enjoyable while being a complete pro.

Colleen’s partners rave about her focus and multitasking expertise. She credits her background in fashion, modeling and television for her uncanny talent for juggling many things at once. “When you only have 15 minutes to eat lunch and get across town to your next show, you learn how to be very efficient.” This efficiency, coupled with a sharp eye, ensures that no opportunity goes unnoticed for her partners, who value how diligent and accessible she is. 

Colleen arrived in New York years ago and hit the ground running. After a decade of being a muse, she has a natural way of taking a team's ideas and bringing them to life. “Colleen made a difficult process very easy. I felt like I was finding my new home with a friend,” one of her partners recently said. 

Colleen realizes that each individual’s time is important. She prides herself on providing a refreshing, stress-free, even fun experience for everyone she works with. She takes the time to explain all the possibilities and listens to your needs with as much care and attention. Colleen has been able to negotiate things that her clients didn’t even know they wanted. “I want my partners to feel the excitement I feel when I go to work every morning. I find it very fulfilling to bring ideas to life and I look forward to doing that for you!”

Renter Reviews of Colleen


Maddie ****

review date 01/26/2015 overall rating
It's been crazy and time consuming moving in this city, but I had to take the extra time to share my positive experience working with Ms. Koltick.

She was on the ball and knows this city inside out. She responded to every call promptly and reassured me of her expertise of the city as she was quick to answer any of my inquiries with upmost confidence and accuracy.

She understood my needs and wants, yet went above and beyond. I was very specific in what I wanted and where I wanted. She showed me several apartments but would suggest looking outside of my "limitations". I was hesitant and hell bent on certain areas and amenities….But she was right! (There! I said it, Colleen!)

You may write off neighborhoods and other things and then you find yourself nowhere!

Do yourself a favor- call Colleen. She has a way of knowing what people want and how to find it. Its a special trait to find in an agent. Getting what you want is hard in this city for the "right price." If she doesn't get that for you…she'll get you pretty damn close.

I'd recommend her to anyone without hesitation.


I rented an apartment from this agent.


Hilary ****

review date 01/20/2015 overall rating
I work in fashion, I have two dogs and I insist on having a doorman. I DO NOT have a ton of time to deal with apartment searching but I initially felt I could find a place on my own. Saving money is a big thing for me and it should be easy right?! After looking for a place for a week and being dragged around by a bunch of brokers (whom I felt could care less about me) I found Colleen Koltick. I truly recommend her to anyone looking to be taken care of properly. She went above and beyond what I could have expected. She was the first person to explain the 'market' to me, how the process actually worked and what to expect. She even met with me prior to visiting places so she could get an idea of what I liked. We ended up finding me a great spot in the West Village that allowed my dogs. End of story, we have space for the puppies, an awesome rooftop and are close to the everything. Colleen was professional, understood me and ultimately is the reason I am happy in my new home. Call her!

I rented an apartment from this agent.


Katherine ****

review date 01/20/2015 overall rating
I highly recommend working with Colleen. I recently accepted a job offer in NYC, relocating from LA. Searching for an apartment in New York when coming from sunny LA was a bit of a shock. I wanted a bright, open loft space and I pretty much demanded the world from Colleen. I was very impressed that she took the time to learn my aesthetic and instinctively took me to places that suited my needs. She paid attention to where I worked so I could get to and from my job and home easily. Colleen also made sure to prep me for what to expect during the application process. So much paperwork! She helped me organize everything ahead of time which made things a lot easier during this cross-country move. She was patient, gave me a tour of the best options and we found an AMAZING place in Tribeca that I'm madly in love with. If you want to be pampered by someone who knows the city Colleen is your go-to. I will absolutely recommend her to my friends and anyone needing help navigating the city.

I rented an apartment from this agent.


Jacqui ****

review date 09/06/2013 overall rating
Colleen is awesome! Extremely professional in every way and very knowledgeable about downtown. I was trying to find a cute East Village spot and after being given the run around from multiple brokers she saved me. She was patient and understanding. Also fun to be around! Call her!

I rented an apartment from this agent.


Wilson ****

review date 04/07/2013 overall rating
I first contacted Colleen about some listings she had in Long Island City. I heard back from her almost immediately, and I had no trouble getting a great tour of the apartments and buildings I was interested in. She was very communicative throughout the entire process, and kept me updated with new listings I might be interested in. She was very flexible with showings, which is important to me since I don't have many opportunities to see apartments during work hours. I'd definitely recommend contacting her, especially if you're interested in Long Island City luxury buildings.

I did not rent an apartment from this agent.

Share Colleen's profile

View all »

Colleen's Apartments

5br, Tribeca, $8,995

5br, Tribeca, $8,995

2200 Sq. Ft., Pets Allowed, Elevator, In-Unit Laundry
4 Days since update
3br, Clinton, $9,000

3br, Clinton, $9,000

2100 Sq. Ft., Pets Allowed, In-Unit Laundry, Backyard, Outdoor Space
18 Days since update

Colleen's Specialties


Chelsea, East Village, Financial District, Flatiron District, Gramercy Park, Greenwich Village, Lower East Side, Meatpacking District, Midtown Center, Midtown East, Midtown South Central, Murray Hill, NoHo, NoLita, SoHo, Tribeca, Union Square, West Village